melanie amaro

Melanie won the X Factor competition and I am happy for her.She has a very good voice, she deserves it , she will work hard etc. etc.  But as I was watching the show I thought Josh was more polished and comfortable as a performer.  Also I wonder if because of his age, this might have been his last chance.  Will opportunities come to him at age 30 just from appearing on this show?  I hope so cause I think his choice of music will be more interesting than Melanie's.  He doesn't look like a star however and she does. Crazy me, I voted for both of them.